NSW Supreme Court slaps down public health order challenges

The NSW Supreme Court has dismissed two cases challenging the validity of COVID vaccine mandates for certain activities, including the ability to work in a number of industries.

14 comments

COURTS SHOW THEIR COLOURS

Two legal challenges to NSW public health orders that restrict the activities of residents who have not been vaccinated against COVID-19 – including their ability to work in certain industries – has been dismissed by the state’s Supreme Court.

The lawsuits were brought by multiple plaintiffs, including aged care workers Natasha Henry and Selina Crowe, paramedic John Larter, high school special education teacher Julie Ramos, and construction worker Al-Munir Kassam.

Other plaintiffs included a pregnant woman who is a staff member of Laverty Pathology and a worker at Bankstown Hospital.

Justice Beech-Jones said the plaintiffs “all state they have made an informed choice to refuse to be vaccinated and sought for the public health orders requiring them to be vaccinated to be declared invalid.”

This includes those that mandate vaccines for health and aged care workers, NSW Police, staff in public schools and preschools and the construction industry.

Their lawyers told Justice Robert Beech-Jones the orders were an attempt to coerce their clients into receiving a vaccination and discriminate against a minority group.

But the judge says the rules are really a temporary restriction on movement, which the plaintiffs could avoid if they decided to get vaccinated.

He found orders that differentiate between people based on vax status are not arbitrary:

“Instead, it applies a discrimen, namely vaccination status, that on the evidence and the approach taken by the Minister is very much consistent with the objects of the Public Health Act.”

The judge said it is not the role of the court to determine the efficacy of the response, the level of power involved or personal circumstances, rather, they are only there to discuss the validity of the legislation itself — to which it is not impeding the right to bodily function or other rights:

“It is not the court’s function to “conclusively resolve legitimate debates concerning the appropriate treatments for COVID-19 or the effectiveness of the vaccines”.

“Those are matters of merits, policy and fact for the decision-maker, not the court.”

Rather, it was the court’s function only to determine the legality of orders made under the Public Health Act.

In his reasons for dismissing the challenge, Justice Beech-Jones said “so far as the right to bodily integrity is concerned, it is not violated as the impugned orders do not authorise the involuntary vaccination of anyone.”

The judgment was broadcasted on YouTube (now unavailable), as each hearing of the case has been since it was first listed in early September. Over 40,000 people tuned in live.

Before today, the court’s streams have received 1,412,278 views, including nearly 390,000 on day one of the hearing proper on September 30, data from the court states.


Ethan Nash commented on this decision: “A noble effort, but the courts have always been a side-wing of the corrupt system, no different to mass media conglomerates that act as the PR wing of authorities. As has been said before, there are rights, and there are realities. It’s time to stop relying on internal sources to give you back rights that were originally taken by the same system.”


READ THE FULL JUDGEMENT:

https://www.caselaw.nsw.gov.au/
decision/17c7d62628b9735ac213a597

(Scroll down the page past the contents)


Advertisements


KEEP UP-TO-DATE

For more TOTT News, follow us for exclusive content:

Facebook — Facebook.com/TOTTNews

YouTube — YouTube.com/TOTTNews

Instagram — Instagram.com/TOTTNews

Twitter — Twitter.com/EthanTOTT


14 comments on “NSW Supreme Court slaps down public health order challenges”

  1. So disappointed, what did we expect with the corrupt court system, we need to take this to the High Court and argue the mandate against the Constitution.

    1. Sage Mahathir Mohamad has long said that not only states want to rule. Since 2020, national sovereignty has become de facto secondary, or even decorative. Behind the backs of the “commoners”, obviously, a consensus of “superhumans” has been established, providing for how to “build” everyone. With the help of the Regional Court of Victoria, it’s not easy to curb their appetites and disrupt their plans, is it?

  2. Well no surprises here. As I stated in a previous post, the Jesuits have managed to get their people in all the key positions prior to 2020 just before the start of the plandemic so they could then unabatedly and unchallenged, implement the biggest hoax of all times, to get people to submit and create their NWO, create two classes of citizens and bring back slavery and finally enforce a Sun-day law for worship in place of the 7th day sabbath, as the bible predicts.

    When something is biblically predicted, it will undoubtedly come to pass as the bible is the truth and the word of God. The beast ( the papal man of Rome), who has been given power by the Dragon ( Lucifer ) is behind all of this. Just wait and watch it all unravel soon.

    “For we wrestle not against flesh and blood ( humans ), but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world, against spiritual wickedness in high places.”

    ” And they worshipped the dragon which gave power unto the beast: and they worshipped the beast, saying, Who is like unto the beast? who is able to make war with him? ”

    No one can make war with him. Only Michael the Archangel can make war with him and win this war and put an end to all of this. Alas, many do not want to hear and think they can win this battle using mere human efforts. This will unfortunately not be so unless GOD allows it.

    But fear not, one day soon, Michael will judge them all individually with the same measure they used, for doing what they have done to humanity.

    1. Well done Jan…

      Godfrey: you were starting to make too many connections. If you are still alive, good luck brother.

      I’m only going to say this one more time keeping it simple – for those with eyes to see.
      Luciferian MK agenda…
      The “shot” the “vaxx” is 80 years of Chemtrails on steroids.
      Chemtrails are neurotoxins – micronised heavy metals, nano tec and bio organisms added over time as they were developed through the MKULTRA sub-projects here in Australia and elsewhere.

      Ric: if you or ASIO send one more operative, you know how this plays out.

  3. There is no remedy to be found in this corrupt system, one must simply pull away and stop supporting this corrupt system!

  4. Stages; 1) fear, 2) control, 3) memory RNA dispersed, 4) train-wreck economy, 5) new cashless system, 6a) replace vax endless booster shots with durable chip, 6b) two tier society… the non-compliant anti-vax into internment camps, 7) remaining population centralised; “pack ’em & stack ’em” 8) de-pop ” get rid of the useless eaters”, 9) return the outer-lands to the wild animals, 10) no private vehicles, cars only for corporation use.
    UMMM? Did I omit anything?

  5. Hope I get a better judge than this for MY case on October 25th, viz upholding my bodily integrity and the Nuremberg Code by refusing to submit to the fake, invasive, DNA-harvesting covid PCR “test”. Wonder if I can still belong to TOTT News if I end up “inside”? Because my heinous crime carries (in SA) a maximum penalty of $20,000 or two years in gaol. Anyone still not convinced we live under medical tyranny in the Vacci-Nation of Ozcatraz, formerly known as Australia?

    1. I wish you the very best with your case, be proud for standing up and stay strong and free…Good luck to you 👍

Leave a Reply